foreword
Most glass collectors are, in my opinion, far too fussy when it comes to condition. It is true that if a piece is relatively common, or recently made, it is more important (and certainly easier) to acquire one in good condition
But most glass, just like china, was made for practical use, and very few pieces that have survived any length of time will have done so in pristine condition. While china collectors, however, will tolerate small chips, crazing, scuffing, cracks (with or without rivets) and even restored pieces, glass collectors are generally very unforgiving of the slightest damage. Even more astonishingly, some collectors will refuse otherwise perfect pieces (even Victorian or older) with minute manufacturing imperfections, such as tiny pieces of slag or bubbles in the body or small crease-lines from the press-moulds!
However, as Eric Knowles (for those who have never heard of him, he is a well-known British antiques expert) has gone on record as saying, some damage on older and rarer items is permissible, and will have no significant effect on value. To take an extreme example, if you look at museum collections, you will see glass antiquities that have been completely shattered and then glued back together
A shallow chip, a small bruise, a slight bloom of water-damage, a few surface scratches or a small amount of lost or worn enamelling or gilding should not be allowed to put you off, especially if the alternative is to have a long-term glaring gap in your collection
More serious damage such as larger chips, more extensive scratching or water-damage, or loss of a large proportion of enamelling or gilding may still be worth considering if the piece is sufficiently old or rare. I would not, however, recommend buying anything with a crack in it, or which has been broken and restored by glueing or riveting, or extensively cut or ground down, unless it is practically unique
So if you do see a piece that has been missing from your collection for a long time, but has a little damage, I would advise you to buy it (assuming the price reflects the condition). How long are you going to have to wait, you should ask yourself, before you find a perfect example?
Having bought your slightly damaged piece, you may want to start doing your own repairs and restoration (you brave person!). If so, read on